First Principles Thinking

Most advisory firms would not perform better by delivering better solutions to a problem. They would produce more durable solutions by asking better questions to define the actual problem.

01

The analogy trap

Faced with a hard problem, most people and organisations do something entirely reasonable: they look at how a similar problem has been solved elsewhere, and apply the solutions to their problem. In some cases this can work when the complexity is not too high.

It is also the reason problems often do not get solved, because the solution has been selected based on superficial similarities, instead of a fundamental understanding of the problem. The borrowed solution quietly fails, and it's rarely clear why because nobody checked whether the assumptions behind it actually held here.

First Principles Thinking starts from a different question. Instead of what's worked before?, it asks what do we actually know to be true about this situation? From these First Principles it reasons towards a custom-made solution, which is much more likely to be durable.

02

Where this shows up

03

How we work

TKD advisory starts with the problem, not the framework. Before any solution is on the table, it examines what's actually being assumed about the situation, and separates what's genuinely true from what's simply familiar or generally accepted.

The specific activities vary with the problem: what's relevant to test in a policy review looks different from what's relevant in a program redesign. What stays constant is the structure: evidence is gathered specifically to test the assumptions the current approach is standing on, not simply to inform a solution that's already been half-decided.

Only once that is established does TKD advisory start building toward a solution. A genuinely first-principles answer to your problem won't look like the answer to anyone else's.

Teams can also learn the method themselves, on a problem of their own, in a First Principles Thinking Workshop.

04

The method

Every engagement follows the same five steps. What fills them depends on the problem. The structure of the method, and deliberately not rushing to a solution, is the point.

  1. 01

    Problem

    Define who is affected, where, and how big the problem really is. Be as precise as possible.

  2. 02

    Objective

    Set one measurable goal, kept free of any solution.

  3. 03

    Obstacles

    Name what actually stands in the way of achieving the goal.

  4. 04

    First principles

    Strip away what is assumed until only what is known to be true remains.

  5. 05

    Direction

    Build the solution from those principles. Start the conversation with the most ambitious version in mind, and work towards it in steps.

Assumptions are tested at every step

→ See the method worked through on a real Australian problem: single use coffee cups
If your organisation is working on a problem that has seen multiple costly iterations and still is not resolved

That is usually a sign the problem itself has not been properly defined yet.

Let's talk it through or call +61 475 923 987

Want your team to work this way itself?

In the First Principles Thinking Workshop, your team spends a full day on a real problem of its own. It leaves with a worked-through case, a method to reuse, and a shared language for the problem. One day, up to ten people.

More on the workshop