Most organisations facing a difficult strategic problem do something entirely reasonable: they look at how a similar problem has been solved somewhere else and apply it to their own. However, for complex problems this rarely delivers the right solution on the first attempt. And having many iteration rounds is costly in both funds and human resources. That is why First Principles Thinking starts by asking a more fundamental question, before even imagining a solution direction: what is it that we actually know to be true about our problem? This approach changes how an advisory engagement runs, from the first conversation to the final recommendation.

01 · Introduction

Reasoning from the ground up, instead of by analogy

Usual advisory projects work with the same elements: precedent, sector knowledge, and received wisdom. They adapt what worked elsewhere and apply it here.

This is reasoning by analogy. It is fast, and can be adequate. However, in complex and novel situations, it is the reason the problem often does not get solved.

Rather than starting with precedent and iteration, First Principles Thinking starts by stripping the problem back to its most fundamental elements: the things that are demonstrably true. It then builds a solution from these principles. As we defined it at the Factory for Innovative Policy Solutions, First Principles Thinking is a technique that guides you to systematically come up with new solutions by critically questioning the assumptions embedded in the problem, getting to its core, and asking what solutions are actually addressing our issue.

The method has a long history. Aristotle described a first principle as the first basis from which a thing is known. It has since been applied across science, engineering, and philosophy. In more recent decades, it has become associated with business leaders like Jeff Bezos, who identified the same discipline in his instruction to resist proxies, and Nobel laureate Richard Feynman in his academic research. What these practitioners share is a method for critical thinking: the refusal to accept an inherited framing of a problem as the only possible one.

This is the same way of thinking that complex and societal challenges require, but almost never receive.

02 · Who it's for

Who First Principles Thinking is for

First Principles Thinking as a way of thinking is more common in engineering and the natural sciences, where the laws of physics set hard constraints on what is possible. Engineers cannot negotiate with gravity. That discipline, working from what is demonstrably true, makes First Principles Thinking so powerful in technical domains.

Nevertheless, this method is even more necessary in domains where the constraints are social, political, and institutional, because those constraints are often more likely to be assumed or subjective than factual.

An engineer who assumes that laws of physics work differently will fail. An organisation that makes assumptions that a social problem needs to be addressed with a specific policy lever as intervention, or through stakeholder alignment, may never be proven wrong because the effects come slowly or failure can be attributed to external circumstances. Having worked in the Dutch public sector for years as an internal and external advisor, I have often had discussions with policy advisors on their reasoning and expectation that a policy solution or intervention was going to be successful. But when I would ask them for the causal proof they could not show it, they had to admit that they assumed it because it worked somewhere else, or they had to confide that this was simply the way it has been done for years.

That is why First Principles Thinking is such a useful method for the challenges faced in public and social sector organisations: social enterprises trying to solve problems that existing systems have failed to address; not-for-profits and charities designing programs under funding pressure of donors; government agencies developing policy in areas where traditional approaches have stopped producing results; advocacy organisations trying to shift commonly accepted reality.

These organisations have the nature of their problem in common. They operate in complex, multi-stakeholder environments where personal perspectives and interests in the status quo are blocking effective measures.

03 · Readiness

The characteristics of organisations that use First Principles Thinking well

Not every organisation is ready for First Principles Thinking. First Principles Thinking has requirements to be used well. Organisations that use it well tend to share four characteristics.

They want a solution to their actual problem, not a solution to a problem similar to theirs

This might sound obvious, but this is often not really the case. In many advisory engagements, the consultants, the peers, or clients proceed by reasoning from analogy. The situation seems similar to what another organisation has faced, so let’s look at what they have tried. Analogy-based advice is not categorically wrong, but it starts with assumptions that may not be true. First Principles Thinking asks a different question: what is thís problem, actually?

Organisations that do well with First Principles Thinking are often organisations that have already tried the analogy-based route and discovered that it did not provide what they were looking for. They have implemented solutions picked from elsewhere and have seen that they did not work for them. They have developed the courage to ask if the problem might be different from how they have been framing it, instead of concluding that the solution was just implemented poorly.

They are willing to question their own assumptions

Every organisation carries assumptions about why the situation is the way it is, what has already been tried, what is politically feasible, what their stakeholders will accept, and what a realistic solution looks like. These assumptions can be reasonable. But they are also often unexamined.

First Principles Thinking examines those assumptions explicitly and systematically. That process is useful, and not always comfortable. It sometimes reveals that a strategy is built on reasoning that no longer holds. Or that a much-discussed constraint is, in fact, a choice. Or that the solution is focusing on a problem that does not matter the most.

Organisations that use First Principles Thinking well are those organisations where leadership is prepared to simply wait and see what the analysis delivers and to work with the picture that is painted, including conclusions that challenge existing ways of working. This takes a specific kind of intellectual courage: the willingness to be wrong about the framing before committing to the solution. The governmental organisations where I have seen this mentality often had recently changed their leadership, or were organisations that had very high pressure from different directions to deliver a solution, as what they were currently offering was not satisfactory for anyone.

An example of this occurred at a ministry I advised on implementing programme management because the civil servants were suffering from the unpredictability of the work. At this ministry, most managers came from executive agencies, where they predominantly worked on projects and programmes. They were reluctant to accept that policy development can be planned. Underlying that reluctance was the assumption that something as fluid as policy development, in a political context, cannot be planned as strictly as projects, like infrastructure. Once the managers accepted that the process of policy development can be planned like a project, rather than the specifics of the policy itself, it became possible to change the way of working, to the benefit of the civil servants, as they were no longer driven only by the urgencies of the day.

They want to find the true elements of the problem, because that is where the leverage is for an effective and efficient solution

One of the most important insights on First Principles Thinking is that complex problems often contain a small number of foundational elements that can unlock leapfrogs and savings. The goal of the first principles analysis is to identify these elements and label what is fundamentally true, from what is assumed, inherited, or simply a habit.

Organisations that truly understand their problem can allocate scarce resources (time, money, leadership attention, political capital) with much better precision. They stop spending energy on interventions that address symptoms rather than causes, and stop attempting in the wrong direction. Sometimes shortcuts can be discovered that were invisible when the problem was addressed from the accepted framing.

For purpose-driven organisations, the difference between an intervention that addresses a root cause and one that manages a symptom is often the difference between impact that compounds over time and expenditure that needs to be repeated through iterations.

They understand that better problem definition leads to better outcomes, and better evidence of those outcomes

The pressure for purpose-driven organisations to demonstrate impact is growing. Funders, boards, and the public increasingly expect organisations to demonstrate the results of delivered services, as well as the effects and outcomes of those results. People want to see that the services made a measurable difference to a clearly defined problem.

But impact measurement can only be as good as the problem definition that precedes it. This connection is often overlooked.

Measuring outcomes against a problem that has not been accurately defined, or outcome indicators that have been selected after intervention, produces data that is internally consistent but strategically misleading.

When First Principles Thinking is applied at the start of strategy or program design, it sharpens the problem definition and with it the impact measurement that follows because it makes it possible to truly comprehend the distance that needs to be crossed from situation A to B. The question of what success looks like becomes answerable, because the question of what the actual problem is has been answered first.

The ability to communicate the distance from situation A to B, with a clear and comprehensible approach, to funders, boards or the public, helps in creating support for your approach. I have seen this mechanism working in the budget negotiation talks in a Dutch ministry. Because one directorate was able to state what outcome they wanted to achieve, and how they were going to achieve that, they received the requested budgets in the first round.

04 · What changes

What changes about the kind of advice you get

So why the title of this article? Because First Principles Thinking changes what an advisory engagement looks like from the start, not only what it concludes.

In a conventional advisory engagement, the advisor arrives with a framework with premade solutions: a methodology and questions to determine in what box your issue fits, and deliverables that have been applied successfully elsewhere. That methodology is often good, but it begins from the advisor's existing understanding of problems like the client's. The diagnosis follows the framework, not the other way around.

In a First Principles engagement, the way of working is ordered differently. The problem is examined before it is categorised. The advisor's first responsibility is to interrogate assumptions: what do we know to be true here, and what is simply accepted? What has been tried before, and what has been tested? What does this problem look like if we approach it without the framing that has already accumulated around it?

Instead of a catalogue of solutions, the advisor brings a disciplined process of inquiry that treats the client's situation on its own terms and for the unique case that it is.

The result is advice that is bespoke to your situation. This ensures that the organisation is also better equipped to implement the advice because it can follow the reasoning towards the solution. Additionally, the organisation is more equipped to tackle the next problem, as they have an accepted problem-solving process and understanding to do it themselves.

05 · In practice

The realities of a First Principles Thinking advisory process

From this article, you can gather that First Principles Thinking asks a lot of an organisation. That is true and not something to shy away from. Nevertheless, it gives a great deal back.

It takes more time upfront than analogy-based advice. The upfront investment in problem definition adds time to the early stages of an engagement. For organisations under urgent operational pressure, this can feel counterintuitive. However, the argument for it is that this approach is more likely to produce a solution that holds, and it is less likely to need many iterations.

It is uncomfortable, in specific ways. Examining assumptions means asking questions about decisions that have already been made, strategies that leaders have publicly committed to, and ways of working that have become part of how the organisation understands itself. That can generate resistance: from colleagues who feel their expertise is being questioned, from managers whose previous decisions are implicitly under review, from stakeholders who have organised their expectations around the existing framing of the problem.

This resistance is normal. Often it means the process is reviewing the assumptions that are blocking a more effective solution. Helping an organisation stay with the process through that phase is a vital part of the advisor's job.

It requires leadership, determination, and a degree of institutional courage. Commissioning a First Principles process signals to the organisation and its stakeholders that the current framing of the problem is open to challenge. Leaders who initiate that process need to be prepared to follow it through: explain why the exercise is happening, accept the discomfort it brings, provide clarity to stakeholders, and act on what is found even when the findings are inconvenient.

The organisations that do this well are usually led by people who want a true answer more than a comfortable one, because their problem is too important to solve partly.

In return, it produces something durable. When a First Principles process works correctly, the output is more than a strategy. It is a shared understanding of why this approach is the right one, based on what is actually true about the problem. That shared understanding is much more robust under pressure than a strategy whose rationale is that this is what similar organisations have done. It gives leaders a backing to return to when questions are raised and stakeholders push back, or when the work gets hard.

For social sector organisations working on problems that will not be solved within a single funding cycle, that durability is the point.


We start with your problem, not our framework.

TKD advisory is a Sydney-based strategy and management advisory firm working with social enterprises, not-for-profits, government agencies, and philanthropic organisations across Australia. We apply First Principles Thinking to help clients understand their biggest strategic challenges and build approaches on what is actually true about their situation.

Are you facing a strategic decision, reconsidering a program’s design, or preparing for a more rigorous approach to impact? We would welcome a conversation. There is no standard agenda for a first conversation.

Help me understand my problem

Free, 45 minutes, no obligation.

or call +61 475 923 987